After implementing the Maratha reservation demand in Maharashtra, Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis is set to make a major change in the Scheduled Caste reservation formula. Speaking at a conclave in Mumbai on the issues of reservation and caste movements, Devendra Fadnavis indicated that a sub-quota within the Scheduled Caste reservation quota will be implemented soon.
Speaking on the reservation issue, Chief Minister Fadnavis said that the OBC reservation has a creamy layer provision, which shows that if a person from the OBC community is affluent, they will not get the benefit of reservation. The benefit of reservation can be availed by the non-creamy layer class of OBCs. The Supreme Court has very clearly explained the creamy layer and non-creamy layer.
‘Reservation classification in one to two months’
Fadnavis said that recently, in one of its orders, the Supreme Court mentioned implementing the creamy layer formula within the Scheduled Castes as well. Even among the Scheduled Castes, in every state, one caste is dominant and is availing the benefits of reservation. Furthermore, the Supreme Court has spoken about classifying Scheduled Caste reservations because many castes in society have not been able to avail the proper benefits of reservation.
The Chief Minister said that the classification of Scheduled Caste reservation will be implemented within one to two months. He informed that a committee has been formed for the distribution of Scheduled Caste reservations. This committee, headed by a former High Court judge, is working on the classification of reservations. The committee’s report is now in its final stages. It will be implemented as soon as the report is received.
13% reservation benefit for Scheduled Castes
Scheduled Castes are currently receiving 13% reservation, and there has been a long-standing demand for classification, meaning a sub-quota within this quota. It is believed that larger castes like Mahar, Charmakar, and Dhor are availing the benefits of reservation, while castes with less representation in the state are not getting the benefit. In such a scenario, the 13% Scheduled Caste reservation will be divided into two parts.
Political debate on reservation classification
There has been a long-standing debate in various states of the country regarding sub-categories within Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, and the OBC class, and their reservation issues. In August 2024, a bench of the Supreme Court, headed by the Chief Justice, ruled that the power to categorize SC-ST reservations lies with the state government.
In every state of the country, there is a dominant caste within the Dalit community. In Bihar, it’s the Paswan; in Uttar Pradesh, it’s the Jatav; and in Maharashtra, it’s the Mahar. These are castes against which other Dalit castes are mobilized for political use. In Maharashtra, the demand for a sub-quota within the Dalit community’s reservation has been raised for a long time.
Mahar vs Non-Mahar in Maharashtra
The Dalit population in Maharashtra, which is around 13 percent, is divided into two parts: Mahar and Non-Mahar. The Mahar caste constituted a little over fifty percent of Maharashtra’s Dalits. When Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar started the Dalit movement, mostly Mahars from his caste joined him. Besides this, other Dalit castes include Mang, Kori, Khatik, Matang, Bhed, Chamar, Dhor, Dom, Aulakh, and Gotraj. When Dr. Ambedkar converted, mostly Mahars became Buddhists.
In Maharashtra, it has often been alleged that the Mahar caste has availed most of the benefits of Dalit reservation, leading to a persistent demand for a separate quota and reservation for non-Mahar castes. Following the Supreme Court’s decision, it has become easier for the state government to take steps to categorize Dalit reservations in Maharashtra, and now Devendra Fadnavis has made a major announcement in this direction.